Skip to main content

When to (re-)evaluate your employer’s benefits

Even if you’re covered through your employer, here are the benefits of getting coverage on your own.

Medical coverage through an employer is more than a common perk in America – it’s become the norm. 

All companies with 50 or more full-time employees are required to provide health coverage to all full-time employees. And many smaller companies still offer health insurance as an employee benefit to help them stay competitive. 

If you’re like over half of Americans, then you’ve got health coverage through your employer. 

But not all employer health plans are created equal.

Some employer health plans include dental, vision, or critical illness or accident coverage. But some only offer reduced dental or vision benefits, while others don’t include any coverage beyond basic medical needs. 

Beyond high monthly premiums or deductibles, there are a few reasons why shopping outside your employer’s plan might make the most sense for you and your family. 

Certain HMO or DHMO plans may keep you from receiving full coverage if you see your favorite doctor or dentist if they’re out of network. And only around 35% of employers offer vision benefits to their employees — which isn’t the best strategy for employers, considering even minor vision problems can reduce your productivity by up to 20%.

Even if you’re covered through your employer, here are the benefits of getting coverage on your own.

High out-of-pocket costs

Out-of-pocket costs like monthly premiums, deductibles, copays and coinsurance can add-up. 

If your employer health care plan is too costly, it may make sense to shop outside of your employer plan to find a plan that fits your budget. 

When you look for a private health plan outside your employer, you can choose a plan that makes sense with your budget. 

You can look for lower-deductible plans with less coverage if that suits your lifestyle. Or you can shop for supplemental insurance coverage like a critical illness plan if expensive health conditions like heart disease run in your family.

If dental or vision coverage isn’t provided by your employer, you can also find these plans through a private provider.

You may be able to save money by bundling your dental or vision benefits with a new health plan outside your employer, or by buying dental or vision separately through a different provider.

Not the right coverage

If you’ve got an active tyke at home whose collisions on the soccer field or epic wipeouts on the ski hill still leave you with hefty out-of-pocket costs, you may need a health plan with more coverage.

Supplemental health plans like accident Insurance through Guardian Direct helps protect you and your family in the case of an accident. And the Organized Sports Benefit adds more cash to your payout in the incident your little athlete has a covered accident while playing an organized sport. 

And if you’ve got a family doctor who you can’t live without, but they’re not in your employer-provided HMO or DHMO, a private PPO or DPPO plan that allows you to see any doctor you want may be a better choice.

On the other hand, if you’re a single entrepreneur who’s tired of paying high premiums for coverage you just don’t need, a lower-deductible plan with less coverage may be the right balance for you.

No dental coverage

Employers aren’t legally required to offer employees dental benefits. But many employers still do: about 50% of companies offer dental insurance.

This is a smart incentive, considering dental benefits are reported to be one of the most highly desired employee benefits. 

If your employer doesn’t offer dental benefits, you have options for finding a dental plan that fits your budget and coverage needs.

You can either:

  1. Purchase your own health plan that includes fuller dental coverage, or 
  2. Purchase dental coverage separately from your health plan.

You can shop for health and dental plans on a private exchange, on the state or federal marketplace. When you fill out an application for a state or federal marketplace, you’ll find out if you qualify for:

  • A health insurance plan with savings on your monthly premiums and out-of-pocket expenses (based on household size and income).
  • Free or low-cost coverage for you and your family through Medicaid or the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP).

No vision coverage

Regular eye exams can help detect more than poor eyesight. Your optometrist can find early signs of diseases like cancer, diabetes, and high blood pressure through your eye-exam.

If vision benefits aren’t included in your employer insurance plan, you can purchase a secondary insurance plan on a state or federal marketplace, or through a private provider.

It can be a relief to have health coverage provided by your employer. But sometimes, you might need to supplement that coverage.

Stay in the know

Sign up to get tips and resources


Brought to you by The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America (Guardian), New York, NY. Material discussed is meant for general illustration and/or informational purposes only and it is not to be construed as tax, legal, investment or medical advice.

Find a Dental plan
that's right for you.

Dental Insurance

Good Health Starts With Your Smile

You're busy and sometimes it’s a challenge to get it all done. Our plans are designed to help make it easier for you to put your health first - starting with your smile. Find a plan that’s right for you.

Accident Insurance

Be Prepared for Life's Surprises

You never expect an accident to happen to you or anyone in your family. Our plans help you deal with surprise costs that go along with them.  Find a plan that’s right for you. 

Pet Insurance

A Smart Choice for Pet Insurance

Now you can get simple, easy, affordable pet insurance and join millions of other happy customers.

Critical Illness Insurance

A Safety Net When You Need It Most

Dealing with a serious illness is tough. Having a financial safety net helps you focus on the fight - not how you'll pay the bills.  Find a plan that’s right for you.